First Sentence:
I was fifteen the day I learned that Ms. Lida Poe had gone missing.
Set in the 1970s, Eskens gifts his readers with a
story that deals with a mystery, bigotry, and a young man growing up in an
environment that makes him decide who and what he believes and for what he
stands
It is so nice to read a book whose story starts on
the first page and continues straight on through; no prologue and a single
Point of View. Beginning with relating a
memory, Eskins' voice as a true storyteller is apparent—"I knew that
President Ford has his hands full trying to beat out an actor named Ronald
Reagan for the Republican nomination, but what any of that had to do with the
price of a turnip down at the IGA--I couldn't tell you."
Eskens creates a sense of time without giving you
a specific date and he creates a sense of place through some of the most evocative
descriptions one will find—"…Soon I found myself sitting in the crux of my
favorite oak tree, watching the afternoon sun ripple across the surface of
Dixon's pond, the smell of mud and water in my nose, the feel of tree bark
under my bare feet." His humor is subtle; it slides in without one really
noticing—"Personally, I didn't find it hard to believe that someone had up
and left Jessup; what baffled me was why more people didn't do
it.
The characters, both good and bad, are real and
recognizable—"Hoke wore his sixty plus years like an old book. ... Sitting
close to him, you could see the loose ends of a past that Hoke never talked
about."
The descriptions of Brodie's life as a teen are
wonderfully representative of life in a rural area have a timelessness about
them, yet we are also reminded of the bigotry that is pervasive in many such
areas--"I mean, there's no reason there ain't no black quarterbacks
playing pro football. They can run as fast
and block and stuff, but they ain't as smart as whites. That don't make 'em bad people. They're just different. ... I think that if a
black man sets his mind to it, he can be just as good as a white man." There is also the pressure to conform and the
way hatred and racism spreads--"You put enough like-minded idiots in a
room, and pretty soon their backward way of thinking starts to take on an air
of legitimacy."
One wants the book to be perfect, and it
nearly is. But not quite. There are a couple of unfortunate and
completely unnecessary portents. There
are coincidences which make one shake one's head believing the author could
have done better. There is a rather predictable
wounding of our hero that feels as though the author watched one too many
detective shows. Fortunately, one can forgive
those weaknesses in contrast to the story of Hoke, his pain, and how he met Brodie,
and how impactful is the story overall.
NOTHING MORE DANGEROUS - VG+
Mystery-Brodie
Sanden-Missouri-1976/Contemp
Eskens,
Allen - Standalone
Mulholland Books - Nov 2019
It sounds as though this has a really strong sense of place and time, and that adds so much to a story, I think. The writing style as you've shared it is really appealing, too. For me, those things and character development can often make up for the things an author doesn't quite get right...
ReplyDeleteThose are definitely things for which I look when I read. If they are well done, I can forgive a weaker plot.
Delete